Exhibit 01 · Competence · The Museum of Lost Confidence

The Museum of Lost Confidence
Exhibit 01: The five-star review
Exploring competence

An imagined exhibit exploring a familiar experience of working life.

Dr Anna Kane | Zest Psychology

I hear it. Why can’t I feel it?

The manager turns the screen towards them.

A customer has written about their knowledge, their patience, and the passion they brought to making sure the customer walked away with the right product.

They are mentioned by name.

“Look at this. You should be proud.”

They read and dismiss every word.

The manager is sharing it because it’s on the website. There was nothing particularly outstanding about that interaction. They helped someone find what they needed.

They smile, say something brief, and return to work.

It could be a review of someone else.

Positive feedback feels so distant. It tumbles off them onto the floor. They don’t really know who these words are describing. They can hear them. The words make sense. But they have no landing place in their body.

The customer’s experience gets explained away. Their understanding of themselves stays much the same.

Perhaps their lived experiences have taught them that it isn’t safe to accept praise. They aren’t consciously thinking about those experiences now. Yet they may still shape what feels possible to receive.

What if they stayed with the review a little longer together? The start of a more meaningful conversation. Recalling the customer, the conversation, how they found the right product. Something may emerge that a brief “well done” passes over.

The review is still there.

Five stars. Their name. A difference someone wanted to acknowledge.

They hear it. What would it mean to let it in?

· Reflection Companion · 

Making room for recognition

Bring to mind some positive feedback you found difficult to receive. What did the person actually notice? What happens in your mind and body as you revisit their words?

You don’t have to feel proud. Could you allow their account to sit alongside your own without immediately explaining it away?

When recognising someone else, be specific about what they did and why it mattered. Leave room for a conversation and allow for different ways to make sense of the feedback.

· The art of the possible ·

What could change if more people in your organisation recognised what they bring?

Someone puts themselves forward for work they would previously have avoided. A customer discovers whose knowledge they can draw on. A manager rewards a strength that has gone unnoticed.

Recognition becomes something people can use.

Imagine what could be possible in your organisation, with capabilities that are already present, but not yet fully recognised.

· The Wider View · 

Confidence can feel like something each person has to work on alone. But as an HR or business leader, you may notice a wider pattern: a team whose contribution is valued by others, yet difficult for its own members to recognise.

How does a team come to recognise its own competence? Whose recognition counts? What gets overlooked?

Come into our Research Lab to explore a team or organisational confidence blocker you’ve noticed. You don’t need to bring your team; just yourself.

Find out what taking part involves.

Images created with AI (ChatGPT), with creative direction by Dr Anna Kane, Zest Psychology.

Subscribe to our blog for updates

[jetpack_subscription_form]

Interested in getting in touch?

x